Want to see a GP? Gipsies come
first as NHS tells doctors that travellers must be seen
at once
Daily Mail
18th June 2009
www.dailymail.co.uk
Gypsies and travellers should
be given priority in NHS
hospitals and GP
surgeries, doctors
have been told. They will be fast-tracked for doctors,
nurses and even some dentist appointments above all other
patients. GPs have also been told to see any travellers
who simply walk in without an appointment, even if all
consultation times for the day are full.
They will also be given longer consultations than other
patients. Five or ten minutes is the average but travellers
will be given 20 minutes and allowed to bring relatives into
the consulting rooms.
Staff will be given 'mandatory cultural awareness' training
so they can fully understand what it is like to be a traveller
or gipsy.
It raises the prospect that other patients will
suffer worse healthcare and have to wait even longer to see
their GP. The guidelines have been introduced because, under
race laws, gipsies and travellers are defined as minority
ethnic groups and the NHS is obliged to consider their special
needs and circumstances. Yet no special treatment is promised
for other groups such as those from the Asian sub-continent
or Africa.
The guidance also encourages Primary Care Trusts
to establish new services for travellers if none exist, and
to designate a senior manager to be a named lead for 'Gipsy
and Traveller Health'. The rules form part of the Primary
Care Service Framework, drawn up by the NHS Primary Care
Commissioning - an advisory service for local health trusts
- to help all PCTs understand the Department of Health's
policy. It will go on trial for between three and five years,
Although PCTs do not necessarily have to follow the guidelines,
they could be breaking human rights law and the Race Relations
Act of 2000 if they do not. Groups covered by the framework
include Scottish gipsy travellers, Welsh gipsies, bargees,
circus and fairground showmen and new travellers.
Tory health spokesman Andrew Lansley said: 'No one should
get priority treatment in the NHS apart from our Armed Forces,
to whom we owe a special debt of gratitude. Decisions about
who should be treated first should be based on a patient's
medical needs, not their ethnic group. NHS managers need
to get off doctors' and nurses' backs and start letting them
get on with what they do best - looking after sick people.
Such a policy of fast-tracking one section of society over
another goes against the founding principles of the NHS.
Labour's botched handling of the new GP contracts and obsession
with a tick-box target culture in the NHS mean many people
find it difficult to get a GP appointment quickly. 'Families
will feel aggrieved that it will now be even harder.'
Mark
Wallace, from the Tax-Payers' Alliance, said: 'This kind
of special treatment is totally uncalled-for and utterly
unjustified. The NHS is meant to treat people equally so
matter who they are or whatever their race. The only priority
should be how ill someone is, not their politically-correct
concerns. This will be incredibly frustrating for people
who have paid tax all their lives to fund the NHS and are
left struggling to get a doctor's appointment and prompt
treatment. Hardworking people will be outraged at this double
standard.'
The NHS estimates there are 120,000 to 300,000
gipsies and travellers in the UK but there are no firm numbers
as the census does not include them as a category. Traveller
spokesman Gratton Puxon, from the illegal camp at Crays Hill
in Essex, welcomed the initiative. He said: 'The problem
stems from years ago when there was simply no access to healthcare,
but things have greatly improved. Health workers visit the
site quite regularly if people have chronic problems.'
The
Department of Health said: 'We are aware that gipsies and
travellers have experienced tremendous difficulties in accessing
primary care. Partly as a result, community members experience
the worst health inequalities of any disadvantaged group.
The framework suggests fast-tracking for two reasons. First,
as a matter of urgency, inroads need to be made into the
health problems of gipsies and travellers. Second, if mobile
community members are not seen quickly, the opportunity could
be lost as they move on or are moved on. This should not
be to the detriment of service provision to the settled community.'
Families living in Calne have hit out at
gypsies who moved their 12 caravans onto a empty site in
the town over the weekend. The caravans were moved into the
field in Lansdowne Park, opposite Honeysuckle Close, on Saturday
but Wiltshire
Council officials have said the families are
only staying on the site temporarily for the next ten days.
A worried neighbour said: "I am shocked
they have managed to get away with this and that no action
appears to have been taken. More
Comments: People make a choice of how the want to live that's
their choice but whilst I am paying my taxes and local government
charges I'd expect equal care, not less.
The Human Rights act is pointless - we are all human,
therefore we should simply all have the same rights!! Also
- Romanies/Gypsies are an Ethnic Group, whereas becoming
a "Traveller" is a
lifestyle choice. I long for the day when this country stops
creating resentment, problems and extra work by making such
minority-focused decisions as this and actually begins to
focus first on resolving the BIG issues which affect everyone!! |